npm and Yarn: Choosing the Right Package Manager

Which package manager is better for your JavaScript project—npm or Yarn?

Managing dependencies can get tricky, but that’s where npm and Yarn come in. These two popular package managers help developers install, update, and manage packages with ease. While they serve the same purpose, they have different features and performance levels.

This article breaks down their key differences, helping you figure out which one suits your project best.

Understanding Package Managers

A package manager automates the process of installing, updating, and removing packages in a JavaScript project. It ensures that all dependencies are correctly installed and managed within the project directory.

What is npm?

npm (Node Package Manager) is the default package manager for Node.js. It interacts with the npm registry to fetch packages and handles package installation efficiently.

Installing npm

When Node.js is installed, npm is automatically available. You can verify the installation using:

1npm -v

​

Installing Packages with npm

To install an installed package, run:

1npm install <package-name>

​

This fetches the latest version from the npm registry unless a specific version is mentioned.

Lock File in npm

npm generates a package-lock.json file, ensuring that the same package versions are installed across different environments.

What is Yarn?

Yarn (Yet Another Resource Negotiator) was introduced as an alternative to npm, addressing issues related to speed and security. It leverages caching and parallel installation to improve performance.

Installing Yarn

To install yarn, use:

1npm install -g yarn

​

Installing Packages with Yarn

To install an installed package, run:

1yarn add <package-name>

​

Unlike npm install, yarn add automatically updates the package.json file.

Lock File in Yarn

Yarn generates a yarn.lock file, ensuring reproducible builds by locking all the packages to exact versions.

Comparing npm and Yarn

Performance and Speed

One of the primary advantages of Yarn is its ability to maximize resource utilization through parallel package installation, reducing overall installation time.

Comparison of Install Speeds

Package Manager	Installation Speed	Caching Mechanism
npm	Slower	Fetches from registry every time
Yarn	Faster	Uses local cache

Security Features

Security is a priority in both npm and Yarn.

npm Security Features

• npm audit detects security vulnerabilities.

• The package-lock file ensures integrity.

Yarn Security Features

• Strict checksum verification for package integrity.

• Supports offline mode, reducing security risks.

Dependency Management

Version Range and Specific Versions

When working with different versions of dependencies, specifying a version range ensures compatibility.

1"dependencies": {
2  "express": "^4.17.1"
3}

​

Symbol	Meaning
^	Allows minor updates
~	Allows patch updates

Upgrading Dependencies

npm Upgrade

To update a package:

1npm update <package-name>

​

To get the latest version:

1npm install <package-name>@latest

​

Yarn Upgrade

To update an installed package, use:

1yarn upgrade <package-name>

​

To upgrade to the latest version, use:

1yarn upgrade latest

​

To upgrade a specific version:

1yarn upgrade package <package-name>@<version>

​

For ensuring yarn set version latest, use:

1yarn set version latest

​

Lock File Management

Both npm and Yarn use lock files to ensure reproducible builds.

Tool	Lock File
npm	package-lock.json
Yarn	yarn.lock

Package-Lock File in Action

When installing dependencies, a package-lock file is generated, which ensures consistent installation across different environments.

Handling Project Dependencies

Both npm and Yarn manage project dependency installation effectively.

To install dependencies using npm:

1npm install

​

To install dependencies using Yarn:

1yarn install

​

Both commands fetch all the dependencies specified in package.json.

Working with Offline Mode

Yarn offers an offline mode that allows package retrieval without an internet connection.

To enable offline mode:

1yarn config set yarn-offline-mirror "./.yarn-cache"

​

This feature helps in saving disk space and improving installation speeds.

Yarn vs npm: Identical Commands

Many commands in yarn npm behave similarly.

Command	npm Equivalent	Yarn Equivalent
Install a package	npm install <package-name>	yarn add <package-name>
Install all dependencies	npm install	yarn install
Upgrade a package	npm update <package-name>	yarn upgrade <package-name>
Remove a package	npm uninstall <package-name>	yarn remove <package-name>

Final Thoughts

Choosing between npm and Yarn depends on project requirements. Yarn is faster, supports offline mode, and has improved security features, while npm is more widely adopted and integrated with Node.js. If speed and resource utilization are priorities, install yarn. For standard Node.js projects, npm install works seamlessly. Both package managers efficiently handle all the packages in a project.

Short on time? Speed things up with DhiWise!

Tired of manually designing screens, coding on weekends, and technical debt? Let DhiWise handle it for you!

You can build an e-commerce store, healthcare app, portfolio, blogging website, social media or admin panel right away. Use our library of 40+ pre-built free templates to create your first application using DhiWise.